[Histonet] Re: ASCP Exam Long opinion

Larry Woody slappycraw <@t> yahoo.com
Fri Feb 2 09:43:21 CST 2007

The histotechnologist never looks at a slide and most Pathologists know little about what goes on in the histology lab. I guess if I'm looking at a morpheaform bcc stained with an H&E I won't know what I'm looking at and the pathologist that I'm looking at the slide with will have no idea where the slide came from. If it happens to need IHC well forget about it! 
  There are people in the field who don't care to learn what they are doing and that along with no mandatory requirements has kept the compensation low. There are plenty of Pathologists out there willing to look at slides with techs and teach them what's going on and vice versa, as well as plenty of Pathologists willing to hire anybody to cut slides on the cheap. Find out how many Pathologists would be in favor of mandatory requirements for Histotechs and you have your answer.

RSRICHMOND <@t> aol.com wrote:
  Comments on this topic have been thoughtful, interesting, and informative!

The American Society for Clinical Pathology (ASCP, it was the American 
Society of Clinical Pathologists when I joined it in 1966, and the change of name 
tells you a lot) is not I think responsible for the lamentably low pay 
histotechnologists receive.

I do think that pathologists need to be much more involved in this issue. 
Most pathologists know little about what goes on the the histology laboratory, 
and this problem needs to be addressed in residency programs. So we have the 
common situation in pathology laboratories - the histotechnologist never looks at 
a slide, and the pathologist never contributes anything but abuse.

I've helped enough candidates find tissue for the practical exam (no, we'll 
have to get tissue from three or four uteri before we get just the right one - 
no, I can't get you a lumbar spinal cord from my next autopsy because I 
haven't got the tools and am not allowed to get them) - and I was surprised to see 
the practical exam eliminated. I think that there could have been some way to 
get the slides looked at without calling a convention. I'd have been happy to 
participate in the judging, but I'm not in anybody's inner circle. 

I wonder if it's time for some organization besides ASCP to set up an 
alternative path to certification, to counter some of the problems developing in the 
ASCP certification.

As Peggy Wenk points out, formal training programs are badly needed - 25 of 
them for the whole USA is a pathetic number. I'd love to work with a community 
college on such a program.

Bob Richmond
Samurai Pathologist
Knoxville TN
Histonet mailing list
Histonet <@t> lists.utsouthwestern.edu

Any questions?  Get answers on any topic at Yahoo! Answers. Try it now.

More information about the Histonet mailing list